Power Query vs Analistable for combining files
By the Analistable team · Updated · 6 min read
Choose Power Query when the same Excel report is rebuilt every week from files in a folder: build the query once and Refresh. Choose Analistable for one-off combines without setup, for mixing Excel files with Google Sheets, and for asking questions of the combined data in plain language. Both keep your data on your own machine.
Part of our guide: How to merge Excel files: every method compared
Side by side
| Power Query (Excel / Power BI) | Analistable | |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | Build a query (minutes to hours) | Drop files or connect sheets |
| Repeatable | Yes — Refresh | Re-drop files or reconnect sheets |
| Stack files | Yes (From Folder, Append) | Yes |
| Join tables | Yes (Merge Queries, 6 join kinds) | Yes, on a column you confirm |
| Google Sheets as a source | Not built in to Excel | Yes |
| Ask questions in plain language | No | Yes (generates read-only SQL) |
| Where it runs | Excel / Power BI on your computer | Your browser (DuckDB-WASM) |
| Data uploaded to a server | No | No |
| Cost | Included with Excel | Free tools; account needed for AI questions |
Power Query is better when…
- The same files arrive every period and the output feeds a fixed Excel report.
- You need detailed transformations — unpivoting, custom columns, parameters.
- Your organisation standardises on Excel and Power BI.
Start with combining files from a folder.
Analistable is better when…
- You need the combined data now and won't repeat the job.
- Some data is in Google Sheets and some in Excel or CSV files.
- The goal is an answer (“top 10 customers by growth across both sources”), not a merged file.
- Colleagues without Power Query skills need to combine data themselves.
Try the free Excel combiner or the Sheets & Excel combiner.
Many teams use both: Power Query for the monthly report, Analistable for the ad-hoc questions in between.
The same task in each
Task: stack twelve monthly sales files and find the top five products by revenue.
| Step | Power Query | Analistable |
|---|---|---|
| Get the files in | Data → Get Data → From Folder → Combine | Drop the files or connect the sheets |
| Fix types and headers | Edit Transform Sample File | Columns matched by header automatically |
| Answer the question | Load to a pivot, sort by revenue, filter top 5 | Ask “top 5 products by revenue” |
| Next month | Add the file, Refresh All | Add the file and ask again |
Power Query takes longer the first time and is faster every month after that. Analistable is faster for the first answer and for questions you didn't plan for.
A join across two sources in each
Task: the customer list is a Google Sheet maintained by the sales team; orders arrive as an Excel export. You want each customer's order total for the quarter, including customers with no orders.
In Power Query, Excel has no built-in Google Sheets connector, so the sheet has to reach Excel as a file first: download it as .xlsx, or publish it to the web as CSV and use Data → From Web with the published link (only acceptable if the data may be public). Then:
- Load the customer data and the orders file as two queries.
- In the orders query, use Group By on Customer ID to sum the amount.
- Merge the customer query with the grouped orders using Left Outer, so customers without orders are kept.
- Replace the nulls in the total column with 0 and load the result.
let
Totals = Table.Group(Orders, {"Customer ID"}, {{"Total", each List.Sum([Amount]), type number}}),
Joined = Table.NestedJoin(Customers, {"Customer ID"}, Totals, {"Customer ID"}, "T", JoinKind.LeftOuter),
Expanded = Table.ExpandTableColumn(Joined, "T", {"Total"}),
Filled = Table.ReplaceValue(Expanded, null, 0, Replacer.ReplaceValue, {"Total"})
in
FilledIn Analistable, connect the Google Sheet, add the Excel file, confirm that Customer ID links the two, and ask “order total per customer this quarter, including customers with no orders”. The answer comes back with the SQL that produced it (a left join and a GROUP BY), so you can check the logic.
Learning curve and maintenance
Power Query's interface records each click as a step in the M language. Simple combines need no code, but anything unusual — keeping columns that only exist in later files, taking the first sheet regardless of its name, handling a renamed column — means editing a step's formula. Queries also depend on paths: move the source folder or rename a sheet and the refresh fails until someone updates the Source step. Budget time for whoever inherits the workbook to learn how it works.
Analistable has less to maintain because there is no pipeline: each question is written fresh against the files you load. The trade-off is that there's no saved sequence of cleaning steps to reapply; if an export needs the same fix every month (splitting a column, unpivoting a matrix), Power Query is the better home for that fix. The detailed traps are covered in combining Excel files with different columns.
Size limits in each
- Excel sheets hold 1,048,576 rows. Power Query itself can process more and load the result to the Data Model (Windows) instead of a sheet.
- Power BI handles much larger datasets than a worksheet and is the natural next step for Power Query users who outgrow Excel.
- A browser tab is limited by your computer's memory. DuckDB is efficient with columnar data, so typical business exports of hundreds of thousands of rows are comfortable on a modern laptop; very large files are better handled in a database or Power BI.
Checking the combined result
Whichever tool you use, verify the output before relying on it. In the Power Query editor, the View tab can show column quality and column distribution, which reveal unexpected nulls and errors after a combine. Add a Group By on the source file name to count rows per file and compare with the originals. In Analistable, read the generated SQL and ask a control question, such as “row count per source file”, to confirm every file loaded. In both, check that the grand total of an amount column equals the sum of the individual files' totals.
Decision guide
| Scenario | Better choice | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly report built from a folder of exports | Power Query | Refresh replaces the whole manual process |
| Exports that need the same reshaping every time | Power Query | The steps are saved and reapplied |
| One-off merge for a meeting this afternoon | Analistable | No query to build |
| Customer list in Google Sheets, orders in Excel | Analistable | Reads both without exporting the sheet |
| Exploring data with questions you didn't plan | Analistable | Ask in plain language, check the SQL |
| Corporate dashboard in Power BI | Power Query | Same engine, same skills |
Privacy in both
Power Query reads files from your disk or your organisation's SharePoint and processes them in Excel on your computer. Analistable reads files in your browser tab using an in-memory database, and never stores spreadsheet contents on its servers — only the model settings, such as which sheets are linked. See our privacy policy for details.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Analistable a replacement for Power Query?
- For ad-hoc combining and questions, often yes. For scheduled, heavily transformed Excel reports, Power Query remains the better fit.
- Does Analistable upload my files?
- No. Files are processed in your browser; only model settings are stored.
- Can Power Query read Google Sheets?
- Not directly in Excel. You can publish a sheet as CSV or export it first; Power BI has a Google Sheets connector.
- Which is easier to learn?
- Analistable, for getting a first answer: you load files and ask. Power Query takes longer to learn but rewards the effort when the same job repeats every month.
- Can I use Power Query on a Mac?
- Yes. Microsoft 365 for Mac includes Power Query with file connectors such as From Folder, though some Windows features, like the Data Model, are not available.