Power BI alternatives for joining spreadsheets
By the Analistable team · Updated · 5 min read
Power BI is overkill if you only need to join a few spreadsheets and get a table out. Its strengths are relationships across many tables, measures, interactive dashboards and scheduled refresh in the Power BI service. For a joined table, Power Query in Excel uses the same engine without a separate app; XLOOKUP handles small lookups; SQL or pandas handle big files; and browser tools answer questions across files without building a model.
Part of our guide: How to merge data in Power BI, Power Query and Tableau
What Power BI is built for
Power BI Desktop combines three things: Power Query for loading and shaping data, a data model with relationships and DAX measures, and a report canvas for visuals. The Power BI service adds sharing, scheduled refresh and access control. Desktop is free to download on Windows; sharing reports in the service generally requires a paid licence for both publisher and viewers unless your organisation has capacity licensing. Check Microsoft's current licensing for specifics.
That stack is excellent for a recurring dashboard over several related tables. It is a lot of machinery for “join these two exports and give me the result”.
Signs Power BI is overkill
- The output you want is a table in Excel, not a dashboard.
- There are two or three sources, joined once or monthly.
- Nobody else needs to view an interactive report.
- You are on a Mac, where Power BI Desktop does not run natively.
- You spend more time on the report canvas than on the question.
The alternatives
| Option | Engine | Output | Fits when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Power Query in Excel | Same Power Query as Power BI | Excel table or Data Model | You want Power BI's merge without the report layer |
| Excel Data Model + PivotTable | Relationships, like Power BI | PivotTable | You need relationships but output in Excel |
| XLOOKUP | Formula | Columns in the sheet | Small, one-off lookups |
| SQL or pandas | DuckDB, SQLite, pandas | Query result or file | Large files, scripted work |
| Analistable | DuckDB in the browser | Answer table plus SQL | Questions across files, Google Sheets, GA4 |
Power Query in Excel: same engine, less overhead
The Merge Queries dialog in Excel is the same one you use in Power BI, with the same join kinds. Load the merged result to a sheet and you have a joined table; load it to the Data Model and you can build PivotTables over more than a million rows. You lose Power BI's visuals and service, which you were not using anyway. Steps: merging tables in Power BI applies almost word for word, and Power Query join kinds explains each option.
Excel's Data Model when you need relationships
Sometimes the reason people reach for Power BI is relationships: orders related to customers related to regions, without flattening everything into one table. Excel has the same idea in its Data Model. Add tables to the model, draw relationships in the diagram view, and build a PivotTable that uses fields from all of them. See joining tables with Excel's Data Model.
Worked example: orders and returns
Question: return rate by product category last quarter. Data: an orders export (4,800 rows) and a returns export (312 rows) joined on order ID, plus a product list for category.
| Category | Orders | Returns | Return rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Footwear | 1,600 | 144 | 9.0% |
| Outerwear | 1,200 | 96 | 8.0% |
| Accessories | 2,000 | 72 | 3.6% |
| Total | 4,800 | 312 | 6.5% |
In Power BI you would load three tables, create relationships, write a DAX measure for return rate and drop it into a table visual. In Excel, a Power Query left join of orders to returns with a flag column, then a PivotTable, gets the same figures. In SQL it is one query:
SELECT p.category,
COUNT(*) AS orders,
COUNT(r.order_id) AS returns,
ROUND(100.0 * COUNT(r.order_id) / COUNT(*), 1) AS return_rate_pct
FROM orders o
JOIN products p ON p.sku = o.sku
LEFT JOIN (SELECT DISTINCT order_id FROM returns) r ON r.order_id = o.order_id
GROUP BY p.category;The DISTINCT guards against an order with two returned lines being counted twice. Analistable writes queries like this from the plain-English question and runs them on the three files in your browser; it does not build a dashboard, which is the trade-off.
SQL and pandas for large or repeated joins
When exports run to millions of rows, both Excel and Power BI Desktop can become slow on an ordinary laptop. DuckDB, SQLite or pandas join files of that size in seconds and write the result wherever you need it. They also make the logic explicit: a reviewer reads one query rather than clicking through applied steps and model relationships. The cost is that someone needs to know the language. Our guides to combining two tables in SQL and pandas merges cover the essentials.
Common join mistakes that look like Power BI problems
- Many-to-many relationships: usually a sign the key is not unique on the side you thought was the lookup table. Deduplicate it first.
- Blank rows in visuals: facts whose key is missing from the dimension table; the same rows an anti join would list.
- Totals that do not add up: duplicated keys after a merge, or a filter direction you did not expect.
These are join problems rather than tool problems, and they appear in every tool on this page. Checking key uniqueness and unmatched counts before building anything avoids most of them.
When Power BI is the right call after all
- Several people need an interactive, filterable report that refreshes on a schedule.
- You have five or more related tables and reusable measures.
- Row-level security matters: different people should see different rows.
- Your organisation already licenses and supports it, so there is help when something breaks.
If those apply, Power BI is well worth learning. If not, see the merge data in Power BI and Tableau hub for lighter routes, or the free combine sheets and Excel tool for a quick merge.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Power BI free?
- Power BI Desktop is a free download for Windows. Sharing and collaborating through the Power BI service generally needs paid licences; check Microsoft's current terms.
- Can I use Power Query without Power BI?
- Yes. Power Query is built into Excel for Windows and, in recent Microsoft 365 versions, Excel for Mac, under Data › Get Data.
- Does Power BI work on Mac?
- Power BI Desktop is Windows-only, with no native Mac version at the time of writing. Mac users can view and do some editing in the Power BI service in a browser, or run Desktop in a Windows virtual machine.
- What is the difference between a merge and a relationship?
- A merge physically combines two tables into one. A relationship keeps them separate and links them at query time, which avoids duplicating data and is what Power BI and Excel's Data Model use.
- Is the Excel Data Model the same as Power BI's model?
- They are built on the same underlying engine and both support relationships and DAX measures. Power BI adds more modelling features, visuals and the sharing service.
- Can Power BI Desktop join Excel files from a folder?
- Yes, with the same Get Data › Folder connector as Excel's Power Query, followed by Merge Queries to join the combined result to another table.
- Can I join Google Sheets data without Power BI?
- Yes: IMPORTRANGE and XLOOKUP inside Sheets for small data, or a tool that reads Google Sheets and other files together for larger questions.