Excel vs Google Sheets for combining data, feature by feature
By the Analistable team · Updated · 5 min read
Excel is stronger for combining data: Power Query appends whole folders of files and performs proper joins, and the Data Model goes beyond the worksheet row limit. Google Sheets is stronger for live collaboration and pulling between spreadsheets with IMPORTRANGE, but it has no built-in join and a 10 million cell cap per spreadsheet. Choose Sheets for small, shared, live data; choose Excel for larger or repeatable merges.
Part of our guide: How to combine data in Google Sheets
Feature comparison
| Task | Excel | Google Sheets |
|---|---|---|
| Append many files | Power Query From Folder | Apps Script or manual import |
| Pull from another file | Power Query or external links | IMPORTRANGE |
| Stack ranges | VSTACK (Microsoft 365) | {range1; range2} or VSTACK |
| Look up a column | XLOOKUP, VLOOKUP | XLOOKUP, VLOOKUP |
| True join (left, inner, anti) | Power Query Merge Queries | No built-in join; formulas or script |
| SQL-like querying | Power Query (M) | QUERY function (single range, no joins) |
| Size limit | 1,048,576 rows per sheet; Data Model beyond | 10 million cells per spreadsheet |
| Live co-editing | Yes in Excel for the web, with limits | Core strength |
| Refresh | Manual or on open; scheduled via other tools | IMPORTRANGE updates automatically |
Excel: Power Query does the heavy lifting
Power Query turns combining into recorded steps. From Folder appends every workbook or CSV in a directory, Append Queries stacks tables, and Merge Queries joins them with a choice of left, right, inner, full or anti joins. The result can be loaded to a sheet or kept in the Data Model for PivotTables over millions of rows. When next month's file lands, Refresh repeats everything.
Desktop Excel on Windows has the fullest Power Query; Excel for Mac has caught up substantially in recent Microsoft 365 versions, and Excel for the web can refresh some queries but has limited editing. Check your version before planning around a connector. Step-by-step: Power Query Append Queries.
Google Sheets: IMPORTRANGE, QUERY and arrays
Sheets combines data with formulas. IMPORTRANGE(url, "Sheet1!A:D") pulls a range from another spreadsheet after a one-time access grant. Curly-brace arrays stack ranges: ={Jan!A2:D; Feb!A2:D}. QUERY then filters and aggregates the result with a SQL-like language:
=QUERY({IMPORTRANGE("url-north","Sales!A2:D"); IMPORTRANGE("url-south","Sales!A2:D")},
"select Col1, sum(Col4) where Col4 is not null group by Col1", 0)QUERY works on one range at a time and cannot join two tables, so a join means an XLOOKUP column or an Apps Script. Many IMPORTRANGE calls slow a spreadsheet down; see combining multiple IMPORTRANGE formulas.
Limits that decide it
- Size: Sheets caps a spreadsheet at 10 million cells. A 26-column export hits that at roughly 384,000 rows, before any formulas.
- Joins: Excel has real join types through Power Query; Sheets needs lookups or code.
- Recalculation: large IMPORTRANGE and QUERY chains in Sheets can take noticeable time to load.
- Collaboration: Sheets wins for many people editing and seeing the same live data.
- Automation: Sheets has Apps Script built in; Excel has Office Scripts (web) and VBA (desktop).
Worked example: four regional trackers
Four regional managers each keep a sales tracker of about 2,000 rows by 12 columns. Head office needs a combined view and revenue by product, joined to a central price list.
| Item | Rows | Columns | Cells |
|---|---|---|---|
| Each tracker | 2,000 | 12 | 24,000 |
| All four combined | 8,000 | 12 | 96,000 |
| Price list | 300 | 4 | 1,200 |
| Total | 8,300 | 97,200 |
At under 100,000 cells this is comfortable in either. If the managers already work in Google Sheets, IMPORTRANGE plus an XLOOKUP column for price is the simplest live solution. If the trackers are Excel files emailed in monthly, Power Query From Folder plus a merge to the price list is more robust. When the trackers are a mix of both, neither app combines them natively; the free combine sheets and Excel tool or Analistable, which loads Excel files and Google Sheets as tables side by side, handles the mixed case.
Joining in each app, step by step
Suppose an Orders table needs each product's category from a Products table. In Excel with Power Query: load both as queries, choose Home › Merge Queries, select Orders then Products, click product_id in each, pick Left Outer, then expand the category column. The merge is now a recorded step, and Power Query will show you how many rows matched in the dialog before you confirm, which is a useful sanity check.
In Google Sheets: add a column to Orders with =XLOOKUP(B2, Products!A:A, Products!C:C, "Not found"), or a single array formula with =ARRAYFORMULA(...) around it so new rows are covered. It works, but there is no join kind to choose, no match count, and duplicates on the Products side are ignored rather than flagged. For one or two columns that is fine; for an anti join (“orders whose product is not in the catalogue”) you filter on “Not found”.
Performance at moderate size
Neither app likes tens of thousands of volatile formulas. In Sheets, every IMPORTRANGE is a network call and every QUERY recalculates when its source changes, so a dashboard built from a dozen imports can take seconds to settle after opening. In Excel, Power Query results are static tables until refreshed, so the workbook stays responsive between refreshes. If a combined Sheets file is becoming sluggish, copying imported data as values on a schedule (via Apps Script) or moving the combining step out of the sheet are the usual fixes.
Collaboration and permissions
IMPORTRANGE respects Google Drive sharing: the person who grants access lets the destination spreadsheet read the source range, and anyone who can view the destination sees the imported data. That is convenient but easy to over-share. In Excel, a Power Query reads files you have access to on your machine or SharePoint; colleagues refreshing it need the same access, which keeps permissions tighter but makes shared refreshes more fragile.
Recommendation
- Small, live data edited by many people: Google Sheets.
- Monthly files, joins, or more than a few hundred thousand rows: Excel with Power Query.
- A mix of Excel files and Google Sheets: export to one format, or use a tool that reads both.
For every Sheets method in detail see the combine data in Google Sheets hub, and for merging whole spreadsheets how to merge Google Sheets into one.
Frequently asked questions
- Does Google Sheets have Power Query?
- No. The closest equivalents are IMPORTRANGE, QUERY, array literals and Apps Script. Connected Sheets brings BigQuery data in but is not a general file combiner.
- Can Google Sheets join two tables?
- Not with a single built-in join. Use XLOOKUP to bring columns across, or Apps Script for anything more complex.
- What is the row limit in Google Sheets?
- There is no separate row limit; the cap is 10 million cells per spreadsheet across all tabs, so the number of rows depends on the number of columns.
- Which is better for a shared team dashboard?
- Google Sheets, if the data is small and several people need to see live figures. Excel for the web can be shared too, but Power Query refreshes work best in desktop Excel.
- Is VSTACK available in Google Sheets?
- Yes. Google Sheets supports VSTACK and HSTACK natively, as well as the older curly-brace array syntax for stacking ranges.
- Can Excel pull data from Google Sheets?
- Yes, if the sheet is published or shared as a CSV link, Power Query can read it with From Web. Private sheets need another route, such as downloading them.